Agonizing
Posted in Blog, Childhood, Punkin on 06/25/2009 05:25 pm by CircusKelli
Dear Tooth Fairy,
This is my very last baby tooth. So this is also my last letter to you. Although I might say hi in some of Sweet Pea and Buddy’s letters. I would like to ask you just a few more questions:
- Do you have any brothers or sisters?
- Do you knit, sew, or weave?
- What is your favorite hobby?
- How old are you?
- Do you celebrate holidays like we do?
- Do you have a big family?
Lots of things have changed since I first started losing teeth. I have braces now. I’m going into 6th grade, and I am 11. (I will be 12 in November. My new cousin will be 1 on the same day.)
Hope you can answer my questions!!
Sincerely,
Punkin
P.S. I have 2 more questions
- Do you keep track of all the teeth each person loses?
- How many teeth have you collected so far? (You can guess if you have to)
Years ago, Punkin began writing letters for the Tooth Fairy each time she lost a tooth. The first letter was sweet and shy with a couple of questions you would expect a little girl would ask of a fairy. “What color is your hair?” and “Do you have a pretty dress? What color is it?”
Awww, right? Punkin’s letter was answered the next night by a typed note from the Tooth Fairy, complete with Tooth Fairy logo stationery. Punkin was thrilled.
The next tooth/letter asked more specific questions about the Tooth Fairy’s house and “Do you have any pets? What are their names?”
Creative thinking/writing cap on, letter answered (after finding another graphic of the Tooth Fairy because the logo from the first letter couldn’t be found). In another typed note, the Tooth Fairy told Punkin that her favorite pet was a puffball named Mr. Tibbles.
Since then, the questions have become more specific and tougher to answer creatively. After leaving a couple of “form letters” from the Tooth Fairy (of the “I have so many letters from so many kids, I can’t always get to all of them” variety) the last two or three of Punkin’s letters have gone unanswered.
Hubby just laughs. I should have seen this coming, huh?
Punkin is a sweet girl. She is eleven years old and is going into middle school in the fall. She has been asking questions about Santa and The Easter Bunny for well over a year now. She is “not sure” about Santa. (Apparently Santa screwed up last year and gave the Chipmunk CDs *she* wanted to her brother and sister, leaving the “less cool” Chipmunk CD for her.)
All of Punkin’s questions about the Easter Bunny were answered honestly because I/we am/are not the Easter Bunny, and because she never came right out and asked “Who IS the Easter Bunny?”
As for the Tooth Fairy, Punkin is “sure” I’m not the Tooth Fairy because (and she has told me this) there is no way I could have come up with a pet puffball named Mr. Tibbles.
Her ‘last letter’ to the Tooth Fairy is above, and I am truly torn about this.
I do not want the other kids to think she is a baby or weird because she believes, nor do I want to stomp all over her beliefs.
On the other hand, it would be kind of fun to include her in on the magic that is the Tooth Fairy. I know she would protect that piece of information from the littler clowns, and that she might enjoy being included in the “grown up” stuff.
Yes, yes, yes… I know she’ll “figure it out on her own”, and I think she may already have. This seems like a good opportunity to reveal it to her, by answering her last letter to the Tooth Fairy.
Thoughts?

